Media Research Center

Free Market Project

3/4/2006 2:47:24 AM

Updated 02/24/06

Free! FMP Headlines
RSS Feed


Boo-Hoo Economics
With the media’s steady stream of tears for a strong economy, it’s no wonder so many Americans think we’re in a recession.

By Dan Gainor
The Boone Pickens Free Market Fellow
Dec. 21, 2005

Send this page to a friend! (click here)     The Christmas shopping season culminated a strong year for the U.S. economy. But instead of ringing out the old year and toasting the economy’s success, 43 percent of Americans think we’re in a recession and that’s a crying shame.

     Call it Boo-Hoo Economics.

     According to the American Research Group, the public is split over the notion that we’re in a recession. It’s no wonder almost half of the American public thinks things are bad, because most people only know what they’re told. For 43 percent of the population to believe something so wrongheaded, there can be only one culprit – the major media. Journalists describe the economy as “strong, but with serious weaknesses” when they are being positive or focus on the “housing bubble” bursting instead of dwelling on the 55 percent gains home prices have made since 2000. They’ve even discussed a possible recession.

     CNN reporter Soledad O’Brien described her view of the economy on the December 5 “American Morning,” that “how Americans are feeling, frankly … is scared. I mean, the war goes on, I look at my heating bill. It may be triple what it was last year.”

     Of course Americans are scared. Why? Because the media have been telling them to be scared. In the December 4 “This Week,” columnist George Will said there were two reasons for bad media coverage including the media’s insistence that “All economic news is bad.”

     That certainly was the mindset in 2005. The year was filled with numerous examples of media misstatements, wildly incorrect predictions and good economic news either downplayed or ignored. Journalists cried over ever new bit of money news and warned of disaster at every turn. In the real world, unemployment is at a mere 5.0 percent; GDP growth is at a whopping 4.3 percent; inflation is low and we’ve had 30 straight months of positive job growth.

     Now take a look at one of the biggest news stories of 2005 – Hurricane Katrina and its sister storm Rita. The hurricanes that devastated the Gulf clearly had a powerful economic impact, but that doesn’t mean they were covered in a rational way. At the time of Rita’s landfall, CNN showed more than 20 mentions of the possibility of $4 or $5 gas from at least 12 different reporters in just five days.

     The average price never exceeded $3.06. What’s a 63-percent exaggeration among friends? Just another familiar cry from the gang at CNN.

     Joel Havemann of the Los Angeles Times took a similar doom-and-gloom approach with a September 3 piece, saying Katrina would “probably end the economy's 27-month streak of job gains.” He added that “Katrina's effects — not only on the Gulf Coast regions where it struck but also on the national economy via higher energy prices and disrupted ports — could result in the loss of as many as 500,000 jobs in September, analysts said.”

     Sure, Havemann added “analysts said,” but that isn’t a get-out-of-jail free card. The prediction he wrote about was soon downgraded, though Havemann didn’t say so when he discussed it about a month later. In his October 8 article, he said: “The Labor Department reported Friday that the economy lost a net 35,000 jobs in September, far fewer than the widely predicted decline of 130,000 to 200,000.” Once the final statistics were in, the economy actually gained jobs in September.

     It wasn’t just the big stories. Economic and business issues were poorly reported across the board. Inflation, consumer confidence, housing and taxes were subject to substantial misreporting.

     Now the latest example of this crying wolf involves the Consumer Price Index, a measure of the things we all buy in our daily lives. It’s comes out each month and is used to track the cost of living. On October 14, CNN’s Lou Dobbs – the network’s own Howard Beale – discussed the September CPI report, warning: “Tonight middle class Americans and those who aspire to the middle class face a growing cost of living crisis. Inflation last month up at the fastest pace in 25 years, while wages are falling.”

     But when the Labor Department released numbers last week showing that inflation had declined by the greatest percentage in 56 years, Lou was nowhere to be found.

     Now you know the true origin of the word “de-pressed” – to have the media lament news about the economy. Only this isn’t just the media version of the little boy who cried wolf. This is an ongoing and consistent attempt to depict a successful economy as a failure. It’s time we put away our hankies, got mad and demanded the media do a better job.

Dan Gainor is a career journalist and The Boone Pickens Free Market Fellow. He is also director of the Media Research Center’s Free Market Project


Send this page to a friend! (click here)